Fishing in Herkimer County, New York
198 public waters in the Capital-Mohawk region — 158 lakes/reservoirs and 40 rivers. Every one is fishable on a New York licence.
Lakes & Reservoirs
- Stillwater Reservoir
6,233 acres · 11 species
- West Lake
5,252 acres · 9 species
- Fulton Chain Lakes Lake
3,206 acres · 11 species
- Grass Pond
3,018 acres · 11 species
- Hinckley Reservoir
2,865 acres · 11 species
- Sand Lake
2,846 acres · 11 species
- Wolf Pond
1,448 acres · 9 species
- Mud Lake
1,437 acres · 11 species
- Big Moose Lake
1,233 acres · 11 species
- South Lake
1,188 acres · 11 species
- Woodhull Lake
1,088 acres · 11 species
- South Pond
1,048 acres · 9 species
- Clear Lake
907 acres · 11 species
- Taylor Pond
904 acres · 9 species
- Honnedaga Lake
825 acres · 11 species
- Green Pond
805 acres · 11 species
- Little Moose Lake
804 acres · 11 species
- Moose Pond
700 acres · 9 species
- Clear Pond
654 acres · 9 species
- Nehasane Lake
638 acres · 9 species
- Rock Lake
599 acres · 11 species
- Rock Pond
583 acres · 9 species
- Deer Pond
544 acres · 9 species
- North Lake
466 acres · 11 species
- Limekiln Lake
465 acres · 9 species
- Crooked Lake
458 acres · 11 species
- Salmon Lake
426 acres · 9 species
- Swan Lake
419 acres · 11 species
- Buck Pond
417 acres · 11 species
- Goose Pond
408 acres · 9 species
- Bear Pond
405 acres · 9 species
- Twin Ponds Lake
394 acres · 9 species
- Jerseyfield Lake
381 acres · 9 species
- Cedar Lake
351 acres · 11 species
- Spruce Lake
351 acres · 9 species
- East Pond
347 acres · 11 species
- First Lake
343 acres · 6 species
- Green Lake
318 acres · 11 species
- Bear Lake
308 acres · 11 species
- Moshier Reservoir
308 acres · 11 species
- Mountain Lake
283 acres · 11 species
- Horseshoe Pond
270 acres · 9 species
- Slim Pond
257 acres · 9 species
- Gull Lake
254 acres · 11 species
- Fourth Lake
248 acres · 11 species
- Lake Rondaxe
248 acres · 11 species
- Big Otter Lake
246 acres · 11 species
- Balsam Lake
225 acres · 11 species
- Beaverdam Pond
222 acres · 11 species
- Nicks Lake
209 acres · 11 species
- Second Lake
202 acres · 11 species
- West Pond
200 acres · 11 species
- Mirror Lake
189 acres · 6 species
- Evergreen Lake
188 acres · 6 species
- Mountain Pond
187 acres · 6 species
- White Pond
170 acres · 11 species
- Walker Lake
154 acres · 11 species
- Duck Pond
153 acres · 6 species
- Little Salmon Lake
149 acres · 6 species
- Twitchell Lake
143 acres · 11 species
- Dart Lake
140 acres · 11 species
- Moss Lake
138 acres · 11 species
- Woods Lake
134 acres · 6 species
- Third Lake
131 acres · 11 species
- Shallow Pond
129 acres · 11 species
- Cedar Pond
125 acres · 11 species
- Negro Lake
124 acres · 11 species
- Lyon Lake
123 acres · 11 species
- Chub Pond
123 acres · 11 species
- Klondike Reservoir
113 acres · 11 species
- Weaver Lake
109 acres · 11 species
- Oven Lake
106 acres · 11 species
- Hidden Lake
103 acres · 6 species
- Brewer Lake
100 acres · 11 species
- Witchhopple Lake
97 acres · 11 species
- Lily Lake
86 acres · 6 species
- Little Rock Pond
83 acres · 11 species
- Terror Lake
82 acres · 6 species
- Muskrat Pond
81 acres · 11 species
- Black Creek Lake
79 acres · 6 species
- Little Woodhull Lake
78 acres · 11 species
- Grassy Pond
77 acres · 6 species
- Sunshine Pond
75 acres · 11 species
- Nelson Lake
75 acres · 11 species
- Tamarack Lake
68 acres · 11 species
- Dismal Pond
63 acres · 11 species
- Willys Lake
61 acres · 11 species
- Rose Pond
53 acres · 6 species
- Bubb Lake
53 acres · 11 species
- Butler Lake
50 acres · 6 species
- Safford Pond
49 acres · 11 species
- Middle South Pond
46 acres · 11 species
- Cage Lake
46 acres · 11 species
- Horn Lake
45 acres · 11 species
- Lower South Pond
43 acres · 11 species
- Middle Settlement Lake
43 acres · 11 species
- Moshier Ponds
43 acres · 6 species
- Spring Pond
42 acres · 11 species
- Peaked Mountain Lake
42 acres · 11 species
- Snake Pond
39 acres · 11 species
- Hawk Pond
38 acres · 11 species
- Snyder Lake
36 acres · 11 species
- Boyer Lake
34 acres · 11 species
- Pico Lake
34 acres · 6 species
- Twin Pond
33 acres · 6 species
- Nicks Pond
32 acres · 11 species
- Mays Pond
32 acres · 6 species
- Blackfoot Pond
32 acres · 11 species
- Diana Pond
30 acres · 11 species
- Hitchcock Pond
30 acres · 11 species
- Gull Lakes Lake
28 acres · 6 species
- Sucker Pond
28 acres · 11 species
- Thirsty Pond
28 acres · 11 species
- Baby Lake
27 acres · 11 species
- Fox Pond
26 acres · 11 species
- Cracker Pond
26 acres · 11 species
- Pepperbox Pond
26 acres · 11 species
- Big Five Lake
25 acres · 11 species
- Riley Ponds Lake
25 acres · 11 species
- Lower Beech Ridge Pond
25 acres · 11 species
- Toad Pond
24 acres · 11 species
- Moshier Ponds Lake
23 acres · 11 species
- Lilypad Ponds Lake
23 acres · 11 species
- Soda Pond
22 acres · 11 species
- Sis Lake
22 acres · 11 species
- Sunday Lake
21 acres · 11 species
- Huckleberry Pond
21 acres · 11 species
- Half Moon Pond
21 acres · 11 species
- Stone Dam Lake
20 acres · 11 species
- Loon Hollows Pond
20 acres · 11 species
- Sitz Pond
20 acres · 11 species
- Merriam Lake
20 acres · 11 species
- Cary Lake
19 acres · 11 species
- Little Crooked Lake
19 acres · 11 species
- Jakes Pond
19 acres · 11 species
- Quiver Pond
19 acres · 11 species
- Massawepie Pond
18 acres · 11 species
- Gregg Lake
18 acres · 11 species
- Monument Lake
16 acres · 11 species
- Razorback Pond
16 acres · 11 species
- Upper Beech Ridge Pond
16 acres · 11 species
- Upper South Pond
16 acres · 11 species
- Summit Pond
16 acres · 11 species
- Hyde Pond
15 acres · 11 species
- Higby Twin Ponds Lake
15 acres · 11 species
- Mink Lake
14 acres · 11 species
- Threemile Vly Lake
14 acres · 11 species
- Stink Lake
14 acres · 11 species
- Streeter Fishpond Lake
13 acres · 11 species
- Muir Pond
13 acres · 11 species
- Gal Pond
13 acres · 11 species
- Wilder Pond
12 acres · 11 species
- Emerald Lake
12 acres · 11 species
- Ginger Pond
12 acres · 11 species
- Squash Pond
11 acres · 11 species
- Reeds Pond
11 acres · 11 species
- Adirondack Park Preserve Ponds Lake
11 acres · 11 species
- Cotton Lake
10 acres · 11 species
Rivers
New York Fishing Licence
One New York fishing licence covers every public water in the state. Resident annual is about $34, non-resident about $50, with 3-day and 10-day non-resident permits available. NYS DEC agency lakes and the Beech River lakes need an extra lake permit. Buy at gooutdoorsnew-york.com.
Other New York Counties
